Top Nantucket Hotels for an Unforgettable Stay

We checked thousands of reviews on and to find the best hotels for your stay
Go to Hotel List View map

Nantucket Island, a sparkling gem off the Massachusetts coast, holds a charm that lures travelers from around the globe. Its cobblestone streets, pristine beaches, and historic lighthouses are the perfect backdrop for any getaway, making the choice of accommodation as important as the island itself. That's where the eclectic array of Nantucket hotels comes into play, offering everything from luxurious retreats to quaint, family-run inns, ensuring every visitor finds their perfect match.

Delving into the heart of Nantucket's accommodation scene reveals a world of unparalleled hospitality and unique experiences. Whether you're seeking a beachfront haven where the ocean's whispers lull you to sleep, a downtown hideaway surrounded by bustling bistros and chic boutiques, or a secluded cottage enveloped by lush foliage and floral fragrances, Nantucket's hotels cater to every preference. Each establishment is imbued with the island's distinctive character, promising not just a place to stay, but a gateway to immerse yourself in Nantucket's enchanting lifestyle.

For those venturing into the world of Nantucket hotels, recommendations and insights are invaluable. Understanding the nuances of each option—be it the personalized service of a boutique hotel, the rich history of a converted whaling captain's home, or the modern amenities of a luxury resort—can greatly enhance your island experience. Our guide is designed to unveil the best of Nantucket's accommodations, weaving through the myriad of choices to help you discover the hotel that not only meets your needs but surpasses your expectations for an unforgettable stay.

Show more + Show less -

Our Top 6

(Sorted by rating & number of reviews)

1. White Elephant Village
2. The Nantucket Hotel & Resort
3. Nantucket Inn
4. Jared Coffin House Hotel
5. White Elephant Village
6. 76 Main Hotel

Luxury Nantucket Hotels for the Discerning Traveler

Check Availability

Nantucket
Mar 16, 2026 - Mar 17, 2026

White Elephant Village

9.4

Good

(46 Reviews)

+ 26 photos
The White Elephant not only exemplifies luxury but also demonstrates a commitment to environmental sustainability. This hotel has integrated green initiatives such as electric car charging stations, water conservation measures, and the use of energy-efficient lighting throughout the property. By marrying luxury with sustainability, the White Elephant provides guests with a guilt-free indulgence, enhancing the enjoyment of Nantucket’s natural beauty.
Address: 19 North Water Street
Rating: Good 9.4 (46 Reviews)
Rooms: 50
Price: From 245$

The Nantucket Hotel & Resort

9.1

Good

(33 Reviews)

+ 60 photos
Standing grandly in the heart of Nantucket & Resort offers a timeless appeal, mixing historical charm with modern ease. This family-friendly hotel doesn't skimp on luxury; guests can choose from a variety of rooms, suites, and private cottages, all furnished with a sophisticated island flair. The property features two heated outdoor pools, a state-of-the-art fitness center, and a complimentary shuttle to local beaches and attractions. The hotel's bistro and bar serve up culinary delights that can be enjoyed alongside live entertainment during the summer months. For the youngest guests, a high-quality kids' club offers fun and educational programs. The Nantucket Hotel & Resort stands as a testament to opulent hospitality, where every family member can find their slice of paradise.
Address: 77 Easton Street
Rating: Good 9.1 (33 Reviews)
Rooms: 17
Price: From 915$

Quaint Boutique Nantucket Hotels

For those drawn to the allure of small-scale, personalized accommodations, Nantucket's boutique hotels offer a charming alternative to the grandiose. These establishments pride themselves on their unique character, attentive service, and deep connection to the island's history and culture. Boutique Nantucket hotels often feature locally inspired decor, intimate atmospheres, and a level of exclusivity that can't be found in larger resorts. Guests can expect to form a genuine connection with the place through curated experiences, from bespoke tours to tasting local delicacies prepared by renowned chefs. Here, we highlight three boutique hotels that capture the essence of Nantucket's quaint elegance, making each stay a deeply personal experience.

Nantucket Inn

8.4

Good

(128 Reviews)

+ 109 photos
The Nantucket Inn is renowned for its family-friendly atmosphere, offering a range of amenities designed for family enjoyment. With its complimentary Mom's Breakfast, indoor and outdoor pools, and a free shuttle service to the beach and town, it meets the needs of families looking for a mix of relaxation and adventure. The inn's spacious rooms and family suites, equipped with mini-fridges and microwaves, add another layer of convenience for families with small children. The Nantucket Inn creates a welcoming environment for families, providing the perfect setting for creating lasting memories.
Address: 1 Miller Lane
Rating: Good 8.4 (128 Reviews)
Rooms: 100
Price: From 220$

Jared Coffin House Hotel

8.9

Good

(380 Reviews)

+ 76 photos
One of Nantucket's historic gems, the Jared Coffin House, dates back to the 19th century and offers a blend of historic charm with modern amenities suitable for families. Located in the heart of downtown Nantucket, this hotel provides easy access to the Whaling Museum, perfect for educational family outings. The hotel features larger rooms and suites with the capability of connecting rooms for additional space, catering to family needs. Additionally, its on-site dining options offer convenience and variety catering to all ages, making meal times stress-free for parents.
Address: 29 Broad Street
Rating: Good 8.9 (380 Reviews)
Rooms: 47
Price: From 135$

Family-Friendly Nantucket Hotels

Traveling with family calls for accommodations that not only provide comfort but also ensure entertainment and convenience for every age group. Nantucket's family-friendly hotels stand out by offering spacious accommodations, child-friendly menus, activities, and, in some cases, day camps for children to enjoy the essence of the island while parents can relax or explore on their own. These hotels are designed with the family in mind, featuring amenities such as pools, close proximity to beaches, and rooms equipped with necessities for younger guests. Each hotel listed below not only welcomes families but ensures their stay on Nantucket is as memorable and hassle-free as possible.

White Elephant Village

9.4

Good

(46 Reviews)

+ 26 photos
Overlooking the picturesque Nantucket Harbor, The White Elephant is more than just a hotel; it is an institution that embodies the spirit of island luxury. Spanning several waterfront buildings, this iconic hotel offers a range of accommodation options, each more inviting than the last. Guests can enjoy spacious rooms and suites, many with private decks offering stunning views of the water. The hotel's decor, a blend of classic Nantucket charm and contemporary elegance, creates an atmosphere of serene luxury. On-site amenities include a world-class spa, a gourmet restaurant showcasing local seafood, and exclusive access to a private beach. Personalized services, such as custom yacht charters, enhance the bespoke experience at The White Elephant, making it a standout among Nantucket hotels.
Address: 19 North Water Street
Rating: Good 9.4 (46 Reviews)
Rooms: 50
Price: From 245$

76 Main Hotel

8.9

Good

(66 Reviews)

+ 75 photos
Situated on Nantucket's main thoroughfare, 76 Main offers an intimate retreat right in the heart of the action. This boutique hotel masterfully combines the historic architecture of its building with chic, contemporary interiors. Each room is uniquely styled, featuring vibrant decor and modern technologies, tailored to meet the needs of today's travelers. A highlight of 76 Main is its inviting outdoor patio, where guests can mingle around the fire pit on cool evenings. The hotel's commitment to exceptional service is evident in the personal touches found throughout, from the locally sourced breakfast items to the concierge's insider tips for exploring Nantucket. 76 Main stands out for those seeking a stylish, engaging, and thoroughly modern stay in a boutique hotel setting.
Address: 76 Main Street
Rating: Good 8.9 (66 Reviews)
Rooms: 19
Price: From 373$

Eco-Friendly Nantucket Hotels

As travelers become more environmentally conscious, the demand for accommodations that prioritize sustainability without compromising on luxury or comfort has grown. Nantucket, with its natural beauty and conservation efforts, is home to several hotels that are taking significant steps towards sustainability. These eco-friendly hotels are committed to preserving the island's environment through practices such as using renewable energy sources, offering organic local produce, and minimizing waste. By choosing these accommodations, guests contribute to the conservation efforts while enjoying the serene beauty of Nantucket.